Thanks Ed and Nick for all of your diligence on this problem. Not too excited about the solution, however! Given that I am currently working on new 2.5 site in test folder, and that 1.5 site is currently working ok on front end, do you see any risk in leaving all alone until I can go live with my 2.5 site? I would rather spend my time on the 2.5 site now instead of fixing the 1.5 site which I need to replace anyways...
If there are serious risks to leaving the problem for another 30-60 days, then I will need to focus on it, otherwise... bye bye 1.5... hello 2.5!
Thanks again
Scott
[ps: I did try re-install again and did select reload from server second time, but problem still there]